5 Common Things People Wish They Knew Before Buying Their Engagement Ring

Buying an engagement ring is a huge milestone. It’s exciting, nerve-wracking, and let’s be honest—sometimes a little overwhelming. You want to get it right, not just for your partner, but also for your wallet and peace of mind. The truth is, many guys go into this process without knowing some key things that could make their experience smoother, more affordable, and less stressful.

To help, we surveyed over 300 people who have already gone through the process. The results? Five common things they wish they had known before buying their engagement ring. Let’s dive in.

Key Takeaways

• You Have More Options Than Just Natural Diamonds: Many people assume they must buy a natural diamond, but alternatives like lab-grown diamonds and gemstones (such as moissanite or sapphires) can save you money while still offering beauty and durability.
• Doing Research Can Save You from Costly Mistakes: Not all jewelers are the same, and some use high-pressure sales tactics. Comparing jewelers, understanding pricing, and knowing about maintenance can help you make a smarter purchase.
• Involving Your (Future) Fiancée Can Make the Process Easier: While surprises are romantic, discussing preferences or shopping together can ensure she gets a ring she truly loves while reducing your stress and avoiding expensive returns or resizing costs.

What Makes Ring Buying Stressful and Difficult?

Before we get to the top five insights, let’s talk about why buying an engagement ring can feel like such a challenge.

1. Lack of Knowledge: Unless you're a jeweler, chances are you don’t know much about diamonds, settings, or certifications. This can make you feel out of your depth.
2. Pressure to Get It Right: You want your girlfriend, soon to be fiancée, to love the ring, and you don’t want to mess it up.
   
3. Overwhelming Choices: Cut, clarity, carat, color… the options seem endless.
4. Pricing Confusion: Jewelers throw around numbers, but how do you know you’re actually getting a good deal?
5. Sales Tactics: Some jewelers push hard for upsells, making it tough to know if you’re buying what’s right for you or just what’s best for their commission.

Sound familiar? You’re not alone. Now, let’s get into what you really need to know before you start shopping.

We Surveyed 300 People. Here Are the Top 5 Things People Wish They Would Have Known Before Buying Their Engagement Ring

We wanted to hear directly from people who have been through the engagement ring buying process—what they learned, what they regret, and what they wish they had known before making their purchase. After surveying over 300 couples, we found five key insights that kept coming up. These are the things they wish someone had told them beforehand, and now, we’re passing that knowledge on to you.

#1 - You Don’t Have to Buy a Natural Diamond

We get it— mined, or natural, diamonds are classic. But they’re not your only option. Many couples are opting for more vintage-looking designs that feature alternative gemstones like sapphires, emeralds, or even moissanite. These stones can be just as stunning (and durable) but cost significantly less. If your girlfriend is open to something unique, this is a great way to save money while still getting a beautiful ring.

Choosing a non-diamond stone also gives you the chance to add more personal meaning to the ring. Maybe she loves the hue of a pale pink morganite or the vintage elegance of a deep blue sapphire. These choices can reflect her personality better than a traditional diamond, and they stand out in a crowd. A little creativity here can go a long way in creating a one-of-a-kind piece.

#2 - You Can Get a Lab-Grown Diamond

If you do want a diamond, here’s something that could save you thousands: lab-grown diamonds. They look identical to natural diamonds, are just as durable, and can cost 30-50% less. Plus, they’re usually more ethically sourced, which makes them an appealing choice for couples who prioritize sustainability.

Lab-grown diamonds are real diamonds—same sparkle, same hardness, same overall wow factor. The big difference? They’re created in a lab rather than mined from the earth. That means less environmental impact, no ethical concerns about mining practices, and more bang for your buck. They're also certified just like natural diamonds, so you know exactly what you're getting.

#3 - Not All Jewelers Are Created Equal

Just like in any industry, some jewelers prioritize customer experience and value, while others focus on maximizing profits. Do your research! Read reviews, ask about care and warranties, and compare prices. Some jewelers have transparent pricing and customer-friendly policies, while others use high-pressure tactics and hidden fees. Find a jeweler who actually cares about helping you, not just making a sale.

Also, consider how a jeweler makes you feel during the shopping process. Do they answer your questions without judgment? Do they help educate you or rush you toward a decision? A great jeweler will take time to understand your budget and your partner’s style and help you find something perfect without pushing you to overspend.

At Faithful Platform, we strive to be one of the good ones. Our commitment goes beyond just helping you find the right ring—we’re here to support you every step of the way. From the first consultation to post-purchase care, we make sure our clients feel confident, heard, and cared for. We’re not in the business of one-time transactions; we’re here to build relationships and ensure you feel taken care of long after the ring is on her finger.

#4 - You Don’t Need to Leave Your Girlfriend Out of the Process

There’s this old-school idea that the proposal has to be a complete surprise, including the ring. But let’s be honest— your girlfriend will be the one wearing it every day. More and more couples are shopping together or at least discussing preferences beforehand.

You don’t have to give away the whole surprise, but getting input on styles, stone preferences, and metal types can save you a lot of stress (and money if returns aren’t an option). If you’re unsure how to bring it up, try casually asking, “Hey, have you ever thought about what kind of engagement ring you’d like one day?” Trust us, she’s probably thought about it.
Some couples will shop together for the ring, trying on a multitude of shapes and styles, and then the boyfriend will decide to plan a surprise proposal later. That way, you know she loves the ring,and you still get your big romantic moment. It’s a win-win. Communication here is key, and it can lead to a more meaningful and enjoyable process for both of you.

#5 - How Important Ring Maintenance Is

An engagement ring isn’t a one-time purchase—it’s a lifelong investment. Over time, prongs can loosen, stones can get dirty, and settings can wear down. Regular maintenance is key to keeping it looking great. Before you buy, don’t be afraid to ask about warranties, cleaning services, and whether the jeweler offers free inspections.

Think of ring maintenance like car maintenance— it keeps everything running smoothly and prevents bigger problems down the road. Ask your jeweler what maintenance looks like over the years: how often to check for loose stones, how to clean the ring at home, and whether annual inspections are needed. Taking care of the ring ensures it stays beautiful (and secure) for decades to come.

How to Avoid (or Resolve) Some of These Common Mistakes

Now that you know what to watch out for, here’s how to make sure you avoid these pitfalls:

• Research before you buy: Learn about diamonds, lab-grown alternatives, and pricing.
• Set a budget: Decide what you’re comfortable spending before you start shopping.
• Compare jewelers: Read reviews, ask about return policies, and avoid high-pressure sales.
• Talk to your girlfriend: If she’s open to it, get her input to ensure she loves the ring.
• Plan for maintenance: Ask about warranties and set reminders for regular cleanings.

A little preparation goes a long way in making the ring-buying experience smooth and stress-free. Check out our other blog, 13 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying an Engagement Ring, to further prepare you for this decision.

Let Faithful Platform Help Your Ring Buying Process

At Faithful Platform, we believe buying an engagement ring shouldn’t be stressful or confusing. Our mission is to help couples save money on the ring so they can invest in what really matters—their marriage.

We offer a transparent, educational approach to ring shopping, helping you find a high-quality ring without overpaying. Whether you’re considering a natural diamond, a lab-grown option, or a unique gemstone, we can guide you through the process with honesty and clarity.

Ready to find the perfect ring without the stress? Let’s start your journey today!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What to know before buying an engagement ring?

Before buying an engagement ring, know your budget, research different stone options (including lab-grown diamonds and alternative gemstones), compare jewelers for pricing and policies, and consider involving your girlfriend in the selection process. Also, keep in mind the importance of long-term ring maintenance.

What to avoid when buying an engagement ring?

Avoid rushing into a purchase without research, falling for high-pressure sales tactics, and assuming that all jewelers are the same. Don’t overlook lab-grown diamonds as a cost-effective alternative, and avoid choosing a ring style without considering your partner’s taste. Also, be mindful of long-term maintenance costs and warranties.

What is a realistic amount to spend on an engagement ring?

There’s no strict rule on how much to spend—forget the outdated "three months' salary" guideline. A realistic budget is what you’re comfortable with and what aligns with your financial situation. Many high-quality rings can be found for under $3,000, especially with lab-grown diamonds or alternative gemstones.